ManiLadder: Benchmarking Robot Manipulation Through a Categorized and Multi-Difficulty Level Task Ladder
The ManiLadder preprint introduces a simulation benchmark with 112 manipulation tasks organized into 4 calibrated difficulty levels. Across the benchmark, π_{0.5} achieved 33.5% success with separate task policies versus 8.6% with one jointly trained policy. The benchmark gives robot developers a structured way to examine capability limits across embodiments, object types and manipulation skills.
Can a benchmark calibrated through standardized learning experiments reliably reveal the difficulty levels that manipulation policies can solve across diverse tasks?
Success on familiar picking and placing tasks gives limited information about a policy's ability to handle tighter tolerances, coordinated arms, deformable objects or extended action sequences. Expanding scene and object diversity alone leaves these capability limits difficult to measure. Task geometry, initialization and visual conditions also make intuitive difficulty labels unreliable.
MetaWorld, RoboCasa and LIBERO support evaluation across manipulation tasks and environments. LIBERO and RoboLab include difficulty taxonomies, while other classification approaches use contact modes, skill composition or manually specified predicates. These approaches offer limited consistency across heterogeneous tasks, particularly when complex objects and different embodiments interact.
Built in Genesis, ManiLadder groups 112 tasks into 32 suites, with 8 categories at each of 4 levels. It combines rigid and deformable objects with single-arm and dual-arm grippers or dexterous hands. Simulation uses Franka Panda, LeapHand and selected TidyBot++ tasks. A reference flow-matching policy has 50M trainable parameters and a frozen RADIO visual encoder. Calibration uses 20 demonstrations per task, 40k training steps, batch size 256 and peak success across evaluations every 5k steps. Tasks are adjusted and recalibrated through changes to geometry, initialization, perception and coordination demands. Physical experiments use X-Arm, Meta Quest 3 teleoperation and two RealSense D435i cameras.
Across 112 simulation tasks, π_{0.5} scored 33.5% with single-task training versus 8.6% with all-task joint training, whose total training budget was 112 times the single-task budget. AL@50 requires at least 50% success on 80% of tasks in each attained and lower level. It was 1 for the reference policy and π_{0.5}, and 0 for GPT6-Astra. AL@80 was 0 for all three. In the Level-2 deformable dual-arm gripper suite, GPT6-Astra reached 94.0% versus 30.7% for π_{0.5}, a reported gain of 63.3 percentage points. On 16 Level-2 rigid-body tasks trained jointly for 100k steps, 20, 50, 100 and 200 demonstrations per task yielded 21.4%, 27.8%, 29.6% and 31.8%. Simulation evaluation used 50 episodes per task. Physical evaluation covered 8 tasks across 4 levels, with 20 demonstrations and 50 trials per task. FoldShirt achieved 40% on hardware versus 44% in simulation. BuildTent achieved 0% in both. The physical results broadly preserved the simulated difficulty ordering.
Difficulty depends on the reference policy, demonstration budget and training protocol. Calibration also selects peak evaluation success, and each evaluation uses only 50 episodes. Most environments are controlled tabletop scenes. Physical validation covers 8 tasks on X-Arm, limiting evidence across hardware and deployment conditions. GPT6-Astra receives up to 20 additional exploration episodes and proprioceptive observations, while the standard imitation-learning observations use RGB and instructions, so the comparison combines different learning resources. Total compute cost is not reported in the paper.
Robot-learning developers, manipulation-platform vendors and evaluation teams could use the benchmark now for controlled research comparisons and diagnosis of multi-task learning failures. Using its scores for product qualification would require broader physical validation, representative operating conditions and comparable observation and exploration budgets. A commercial deployment timetable is not reported in the paper.
The full text is not republished here because the paper's license does not allow it. Read the original on arXiv.